Britain’s aid to Rwanda is funding a ‘repressive regime’ says former Kagame official
The former private secretary to the Rwandan President has warned that British aid is bankrolling an unaccountable, repressive regime, accused of war crimes in neigbouring Congo and of killing or jailing dissidents at home and abroad.
David Himbara, who was President Paul Kagame’s right hand man until he fled the country two years ago, said: “Britain is not funding Rwanda. It is funding a dictator. It’s sustaining a bad regime by any measure. Let no British taxpayer flatter herself or himself that they’re helping Rwanda. No, you are merely extending their misery.”
Despite ever-more serious allegations of human rights abuse at home and war-mongering abroad, the UK is planning to give £270-million to Rwanda over the next three years. By then, aid to the country will have nearly doubled since the Conservative-led coalition came to power. Half of that aid will be given directly to the Rwandan government, to spend as it sees fit.
Rwanda relies on foreign aid for nearly half its budget and Britain is its biggest bilateral donor, providing about five per cent of the national budget – more than the Rwandan government allocates to defence spending.
“The United Kingdom’s aid to Rwanda is misplaced. It’s wrong. It cannot be justified,” said Mr Himbara, who now lives in South Africa and is on an alleged Rwandan government hit list. Speaking to Channel 4’s Dispatches in an exclusive interview to be broadcast on Monday Nov 26 he added: “How do you hold people accountable where there is no media, where there is no opposition party, where parliament is answerable to one man?”
The international development secretary, Justine Greening, is to decide next month on whether to hand over the next tranche of aid, totalling £21 million. Her predecessor, Andrew Mitchell, suspended payment of a £16 million instalment after evidence first surfaced that Rwanda was backing the violent rebellion in neighbouring Congo.
Controversially, Mr Mitchell then unfroze that aid in his last day in the job. In evidence to a parliamentary select committee he claimed to have had Downing Street’s approval.
Last week a United Nations report said the Rwandan military was supporting Congolese rebels who took over the eastern city of Goma.
Mr Kagame has long been feted for his leading role in ending the Rwandan genocide, during which an estimated 800,000 members of the Tutsi tribe were murdered by ethnic Hutus. and has been held up as a paragon of modernity and reform.
Both Mr Cameron and Mr Mitchell have travelled to the country to participate in Project Umubano, a Conservative Party social action programme, frequently meeting Mr Kagame. Mr Himbara described Mr Mitchell and other leading Conservatives as “Kagame’s groupies.”
But the relationship has been strained in recent months by accusations made by United Nations investigators over Rwanda’s alleged funding and arming of a rebel force in eastern Congo. This group, known as M23 and whose top commander is wanted for war crimes by the International Criminal Court, has forced at least 500,000 people to flee their homes and last Wednesday seized the regional capital, Goma.
The following day, the United Nations Security Council published its investigators’ findings, naming the Rwandan Defence Minister, General James Kabarabe – a close friend and associate of the President – as the alleged co-ordinator of rebel military operations inside Congo. Rwandan forces, the UN report claims, not only supplied guns, money and recruits, but has engaged directly in combat to help the rebels capture an expanding swath of territory.
The Rwandan government vehemently denies these claims, accusing the UN investigators of seeking to malign Rwanda’s image and dismissing the report as not worth the paper it was written on. President Kagame has joined regional leaders in urging the M23 to pull out of Goma, but has failed to condemn the rebellion.
“The report is not credible,” said Brigadier General Joseph Nzabamwita, Rwanda’s Defence Spokesperson. “It’s wrong. Based on a flawed methodology. The evidence is not there. It’s not there at all. The report is trash.”
In contrast, the British government says it judges the UN evidence to be “credible and compelling”.
On Thursday the William Hague, the Foreign Secretary, and Miss Greening said in a joint statement: “These allegations will necessarily be a key factor in future aid deisions to the Government of Rwanda.”
The promotion of regional peace and security as well as respect for human rights and democratic principles are built into the agreement which governs the aid relationship between Britain and Rwanda. Foreign policy officials claim British aid buys political leverage.
But, speaking in his first full interview since he fled Rwanda, Mr Himbara disagrees. “What leverage would that be?” he asks. “It has not stopped Kagame going into Congo. We have never seen UK say anything about Rwanda, no matter what it does. There is no evidence. [The] UK just gives blank cheques, it seems to me.”
Despite repeated requests, British aid officials in Rwanda were unable to provide specific examples of projects funded by British aid. Nor were they given permission to discuss them on the record. Requests for an interview with Miss Greening were declined.
Britain maintains that it considers the overall “direction of travel” when it looks at Rwanda’s performance on human rights. But there has been no public criticism of widely reported abuses, which have included the jailing of all three opposition party leaders, the decapitation of a deputy opposition leader, the shooting dead of a journalist, and the imprisonment of others. The repression intensified in the run-up to the presidential election in August 2010.
“There is no democracy in Rwanda. There is no political space in Rwanda. There is no free press in Rwanda. There is no independent judiciary in Rwanda,” says Ben Rawlence, an Africa expert at Human Rights Watch. “Senior opposition figures are all in jail, senior journalists are all in jail. There is no independent journalist operating any more. It’s a very scary place.”
David Himbara claims to have been the victim of attempted abduction by Rwandan agents and has been warned by intelligence officials in South Africa, where he now lives, that he is on a Rwandan government hit list. There have been at least seven assassinations or attempted assassinations of Rwandan dissident abroad since 2010. The former army Chief of Staff, narrowly survived assassination in South Africa last year.
Last year, London’s Metropolitan Police even issued “threat to life” warnings to two Rwandan exiles living in the UK. One, Rene Mugenzi – who fled the genocide in 1994 and who has had British citizenship for a decade – was warned: “Reliable intelligence states that the Rwandan Government poses an imminent threat to your life. The threat could come in any form.”
Mr Mugenzi, who stood as a Liberal Democrat candidate in a local election in London last year, had challenged President Kagame’s human rights record live on air in a BBC World Service radio phone-in. Although an alleged assassin was apparently intercepted and refused entry to the UK, he believes the threat is still active.
As a British taxpayer, Mr Mugenzi says: “I feel that I have sponsored my own assassination [and] also the oppression of my own people, because this money is propping up an oppressive regime.”
Asked whether, in light of a litany of serious allegations, Rwanda was complying with commitments it had made in its Memorandum of Understanding with Britain, Louise Mushikiwabo, Rwanda’s Foreign Affairs Minister, was resolute. “No question about it,” she said. “Rwanda has complied 100 per cent.”
She said her country should not be held to standards of behaviour that are unrealistic. “Rwanda is not an angel country – we’ve come from very far; a country where a million plus people get killed in a well-orchestrated genocide. We are moving at our pace with our own choices, not with anybody else’s.”
President Kagame appears to have taken a high stakes gamble. While the accusations against his country are serious, Rwanda will, from January, have a seat on the UN Security Council, which will boost its diplomatic clout and reduce the chances of it facing international isolation.
At a recent African economic conference in Kigali, the president told his audience: “I want to assure you [of] one thing. This new Rwanda: it does not respond well to blackmail.”
Good job Himbara,
Its very good to tell the doners where their taxes go more especially when given to the hands of Kagame.
They should know that their aid is aiding in destroying human race down in sub suharan African poor countries of Congo and Rwanda.
They should be told that any day people will ask their authorities whey they spent their natinal taxes into facilitating rapings and killings of our people.
We shall ask them why they dont respect human rigths organization reports from our perishing people and they listen to them when they talk of their lands!
They shall prove to us if international community is international protecting body that can even care for the poor peasants being killed by blood hungry rulers of Paulo Kagame type who uses their taxes to abuse and defeme human image on the planet of earth.
The world should not accept the powers that a proves killers to negociate for power when killing their nationals at the expence of their minerals.
Long live all of you against the evile man Kagame and his fellow goons!
Who is HIMBARA? is he among the people who Fought for the liberation of RWANDA? or is among those who heard that Rwanda is libarated while eating hamberger there in Europe and USA?
Tell him that what he is saying no person in Rwanda concider them except street boys their who were chased because of their corruption and arogance of hatrade to the poor people.
we know the real Men who struggled including MZEE TITO not HIMBARA!!
Opportunist like Himbara!!!! You are so stupid and INDASHIMA like your group. You want to decive us!! Who can forge you when you was in the Presidency!! UBUSWA, AGASUZUGURU, UBUSHURASHIZI….
Museveni ni umubyenyeyi wacu abatutsi turamukunda cyane. yaradufashije igiye cyose arakagahorane amahora iyo Kabuta Museveni atabaho ntamututsi uba ukiriho haba muburundi cy murwanda cg muri congo Museveni ni imana ya Batutsi turanamwubaha ni umunyakuri arakabo YOWERI MUSEVENI
Ko mutukana ariko mwavuze musenya ibitekerezo byintege nke bya Dr. Himbara David niba bihari ibyomwamuhinduramo imyase mugutekereza bitari kumugira imyase mwitesha agaciro mutukana! Wowe ubaza ngo himbara ntiya Rwanye wowe wafashe akahe gasozi kurwanda wenyine tukakumenya namateka yokubohora urwanda akakuvugaho? Rutaremara uvugako yakoze ibitangaza yakoze iki wenyine adafite abandi harimo nahimbara wari mo kurya neza aho yarari arioko kandi agaragaza isuranziza yurugamba mububasha yahabwaga numwanya yarafite ikyo gihe! Nkunze ko uvuze na Rutaremara ubwo uvuze aba nyamuryango nurugamba murwego rwapolitiki, hariho nurwimbunda, hari nurwumusanzu, hakaba nurwa man power! uwatangaga billion ikyo gihe ayifte nuwatangaga ijana ikyogihe ariryo afite bose babaga bangana mugutanga umusanzu! Uwitanze murwego rwagisirikare nawe akitanga yari officer mungabo nkizibugande nawe ubwitange bwe bwafatwaga nkubwu mwana wacumi nitanu witanze atitangiriye atazigamye ubutobwe nahejohe hazaza.
Wowe wita Himbara opportunist wowe utari opportunist uriki wiyibagiza abana burwanda bicwa bahowe ubusa kubera munyangire babeshyewe, abandi bakazira ikyo bapfana nabandi, abandi bakazira ibitekerezo nubushobozi bwabo, abandi bakazira ukobavutse! Agasuzuguro ka Dr. David Himbara wowe nashobuja Kagame na Himbara ninde usuzugura ushobora Kwita umuntu wigisha kaminuza igicucu? Umugyanama wa perezida ukamwita igicucu ubwose ntuba ututse perezida wawe ubawara mugize umugyanama we?
Ariko mwabagabo mwe cyagwa abagore ikyo mutazi mubikorerwa iwacu niki? amahano akorerwa iwacu ayo mutazi nayahe? Ntawifuza ko iwacu hacanwa umuriro ariko kandi reka ibigoramye bigororwe ubivuze ukobiri nka Dr. Himbara yekwitwa opportunist, haduyi, umusazi, umujura nukuri nimurekere aho! Ariko ntawuzavuga ibigoramye byiwacu uzaba umwere bose bagomba kuba ibwa, ibisambo haduyi, abanzi bigihugu, nibindi bibi nkibyo!!!!!!!!! George Washingtone bamwise amazina menshi, yabaye ibuye rikomeye ryubatse America yunze ubumwe, Kagame yabaye inyanga Rwanda, inyenzi, bamwitaga muzuru ariko ubu ni perezida uganje nuko aganje mubituro byabenegihugube!
Dr. Himbara himbara rwose mwana wadata ubabwire ibitekerezo byawe uhaguruke unabyerekane munzego zose uzi zifatirwamo ibyemezo!!!!!!!!!!!
Ubeho nange mbeho kuzareba abanzi bamahoro bahanwa!
I would thank anyone who could tell us more about the story behind the fallout with Mr Kagame. In the case of Himbara, Marara and the likes before branding Kagame as anything try to tell us the truth about your problems you had with him, I know you cannot.
Another thing is that before saying whatever you want you should have more information about the issue you are raising, one simple thing to tell you is that you might not be happy to know that Rwanda is ranked among the top countries using aid effectively and I am sure you know we don’t attribute this ourselves
You might not be happy to know that our country host different delegations seeking to study our governance system and how we manage aids and grants.
May be you have another plan you think could boost our country image, so come and tell us but in Kigali not from far awayyyyyyyyyyyyyyy there
Rugema, ntabwo nkuzi ariko uzi ukuri. Kandi nabandi barakuzi ariko kubera inda nini no kutabona aho bavugira nuwu bizeye babwira, nuko bigenda. Mubyukuri rero buriya buriganya babeshya bakajijisha amahanga abaturage bapfa, abana bava mumashuri kubera amikoro make, muminsi mike birarangira.
Obama umwana wu mujyaruwa mbona hariya nawe ntabwo yoroheye Kagame Pahulo….
Reka mbwire abunva nkabikindi ariko ntamenyesha abahutu batibuka nkuko yavuze ahubwo abanya Rwanda batibuka!
1. M7 numwana wumuntu se ni Amosi nyina yitwaga Esiteri si Imana yacu aba Tutsi nta nubwo azabayo.
Icyo kumwemera urakoze rwose kuko nange ndamwemera namafutiye menshi cyagwa make nyafata nkayo umuvandimwe yakora kyagwa umubyeyi yewe na Kagame nda mwemera ariko simana ya ba Nya Rwanda numunyafuti utemera ibyo akosamo akanga ko anakosorwa ahubwo agakemuza amafuti ayandi.
Gahanga uravuga ngo ukeneye aho Kagame yaba yaba atarunvikanye na Marara na Himbara nabandi nkawe unongera ko arintahahari ubwose washakaga kuhamenya?
Kuki ugaragaza integenke nyishi mukugaragaza kuba inkuba ihindira inyuma yo gukandamiza ababaye mwana wa data?
Ejo Gahanga bwacya bwakwitiwe ejo bizagende bite?
Gahanga inkunga yu Rwanda ikoreshwa neza ugereranyije nibindi bihugu bibarwa nkibijura! Gaha iyo bavuze ko perezida wu Rwanda yaraye muri Hoteri yibihumbi 20000 Usd uwubwongereza akarara mukyumba kyitarengeje ibihumbi 7000Usd hagaragazwa amafakitiri biba bimenyesha gusasagura kyagwa gukoresha nabi umutungo wigihugu?
Niyo muvuga amazu imiturirwa yubatswe Kigali kuva muwa mirongo 94 kugeza 2012 ndumirw kyane nonese ki itubakwa? abanya Rwanda barakora kandi bakunda u Rwanda ahoyenda ubwiyeko Kagame ariwe wayubatse akayigabira nabayituyemo sha uwamuvuga ho namuvuga umwe ariko kandi ni amadeni abantu bafashe bubaka iwabo!
Uravuga Kigali nonese Juba yamajepfo ya Sudani niba ifite imiturirwa igihe muwi 2007 abantu bararaga mumahe ma nomumazu yanyakatsi muricyo gishanga kya Nile ubu ugeze Juba ukareba Juba 2007 ukareba iya 2012 wavuga uti yego bana babantu mururakora!
Ariko ntituri nka Juba mubukungu, mubantu turi million zigera mri 12 igihe aba Sudani bomumgepfo ya sudani bataragera na million 6.
Man power ikora murikyo gihugu 60 kwijana nabanyamahanga bavu mubihugu byibituranyi nafaranga bahebwe barayakyura iwabo direct.
Ntakyintu nakimwe bihazamo ibintubyose bikoreshwa muri sudan yamagyepfo biva mubihugu byibituranyi none kukyi URwanda? Turifuza igihugu kyacu ko kyigya aho tukyifuza heza ntawuhejwe ntawufuzwe nta wumeneshwa nta wubeshyerwa ntawunyagwa
Ariko uyu Dr HIMBARA igihe cyose yamaze yicaye kuntebe yicyubahiro ntajambo narimwe yigeze avuga, kandi iyo atajya guhunga kubera gutinya gusobanura ruswa nandi makosa aregwa, nubu aba akiri muri iyo myanya ntacyo avuga. Ese iyo kuba mu Rwanda nta democratie, kuba nta political space, ntatangaza makuru nibindi umuntu abibona aruko ahunze igihugu? Cg baba bashaka ko bakora ibibi ngo ntibabibazwe? Abayobozi baragwira koko.
Abanyarwanda bamva mubwoko bwabatutsi munjye mwubahana , munakundane munafatanye munyje ,mwicisa bugufu .