Kagame Victim of Own Success
The world tends to hold him to very high, sometimes unrealistic standards
Over the last one month, a rebellion has been ragging in eastern DRC against the government of President Joseph Kabila in Kinshasa. As I write this article, over 40 armed groups, some of them former members of the Congolese army, have taken up arms against his government. However, international diplomatic activity, media coverage and human rights campaigns have been focused on one rebel group, M23 and one country, Rwanda and its president, Paul Kagame, for allegedly sponsoring the rebellion. Even an interested observer may easily think the rebellion is taking place in Rwanda, not DRC. Why is Kabila against whom mutineers and rebels are battling for control of the DRC missing in the news?Â
Even if we accept, just for argument’s sake, that Rwanda/Kagame are the real force behind – not just M23 – but all the 40 rebellious groups in DRC, would that take focus from Kabila and his government? Last year, there was rebellion in Libya openly supported by NATO whose planes bombed that country every day. However, the focus of the news and diplomacy did not move away from Libya’s ruler Muammar Gadaffi. Equally today, there is a civil war in Syria with the rebels enjoying the active support of the USA, Saudi Arabia and Qatar – with money, arms and propaganda. However, the news coverage is not about those sponsoring the civil war but about the subject of that civil war, President Bashar Asaad.
One could say that perhaps Rwanda/Kagame is the centre of diplomatic activity and news coverage because of their interest in Congolese minerals. But again, when the US went into Iraq, there were widespread accusation of her interest in its oil as the driving motive of the invasion. Last year, there was a lot of news and analysis that NATO’s invasion of Libya was driven by its oil. However, in both cases Saddam Hussein and Gadaffi remained central figures in the story. Hence, the Congo rebellion may be the first in human history where the person at the centre of the news is not the concerned president but the one alleged to be sponsoring the rebels.
The accusations against Rwanda at the Security Council were not presented by Kinshasa but by a UN “panel of experts.†Consequently, even Kinshasa today seems to think the rebellion is not an internal problem but a Rwandan problem. May be this is the reason Kabila proposed at the Kampala summit a “neutral force†to enter his country and fight the rebels and mutineers for him. In many ways therefore, the international community and the news media are helping Kabila avoid responsibility for the problems inside his country. By blaming Rwanda, the media and the international community are actually helping Kabila disregard genuine domestic grievances and thereby undermining his incentives to seek internal political accommodation.
Of course the leaders of DRC are not stupid. They may suspect or even believe that Rwanda is behind the rebellion by M23 and perhaps other groups as well. But they know that many other groups rebelling against Kinshasa have no links to Rwanda whatsoever. In any case, Kinshasa is aware that the mutineers and other rebels have grievances as well. It is of course difficult for Kinshasa to admit its role in sparking these rebellions. However, hiding behind Rwanda may obscure its responsibility in the short term but does not solve its problem in the medium to long term.
So what are the problems with governance in Congo that simulate and stimulate rebellion? Is Rwanda the creator of these problems or an opportunist taking advantage of them? Does Kabila preside over a democracy akin to that of Norway or Sweden that creates rebellion-proof politics? Even Norway last year had its own massacre from a fanatical right wing man – meaning no country is immune to insurrection. If we admit that DRC has serious internal governance problems, can these simulate rebellion? How does a blanket condemnation of Kigali help us craft a solution?
I think Kagame is a major source of trouble for DRC; albeit by default. Under his presidency, Rwanda has made a dramatic turnaround in a very short time. This has inspired many in high and low places; in politics, academia, religion and the media. Kagame/ Rwanda have thus become global super stars. But it has also mobilised many in envy and jealous. Who is Kagame/Rwanda to be so globally feted? The more Rwanda/Kagame get praise, the more others stalk them for any slip. Its success means Rwanda often gets held to very high and sometimes unrealistic standards. And like all strong brands, the success of Kagame has attracted many opportunistic groups and interests that seek to promote their own brand by attacking Rwanda at every opportunity.
This also means that Rwanda’s success becomes a problem for Congo. First, everyone knows that Rwanda has strong and legitimate interests in the Congo given the institutional dysfunctions in that country. They know that Congo poses – not just a tactical or even strategic threat to Rwanda – but rather an existential threat. In geo politics, there is the concept of the “margin of error†which refers to the ratio of a mistake and the consequences of it. When a small mistake can have catastrophic consequences then you have to be hypersensitive. I suspect those who accuse Rwanda of involvement in DRC do not need much evidence. They just extrapolate from the threat it faces to conclude – not that it is involved – but rather that “it has to be involved.â€
But this also means that those blaming Rwanda/Kagame are actually hurting Congo. They are undermining the process of internal evaluation that Congo needs to craft a solution for itself. They are helping Kabila avoid responsibility to his people and country. They are encouraging him burry his head in the sand and imagine that his people are happy with him and it is Kagame either directly invading his country or indirectly sponsoring rebellion against him. And the worst mistake for Congo is to ignore the internal sources of discontent, pretend they do not exist and shift blame to external factors. This is the mistake of the international community.
Source http://in2eastafrica.net/kagame-victim-of-own-success/.
Good analysis! By extrapolation, Rwanda faces threat from Congo. If this is true, who threatens Rwanda from DRC? Congolese or Rwanda?
These are talky-talky-talky! The reality is: Rwanda is a problem for Congo and must get out from Congo. DRC is not a country for taking. Even if it is no-man’s land, people are killed like animals. This must end, and end now.
Rugaruga, the analysis has nothing good at all! why those enemies of Rwanda are not against Singapol or Chain?
The story was just extracted from Rwandan mouth piece Andrew Mwenda’s paper.
Kigali is developing because of all Rwandans not because of Kagame.
Rwandans were even developing at highest rate when they were in exile so it should not be something Kagame has to be praised for instead wanainchi wa Rwanda they deserve the credite.
Kagame is not blamed by western powers only as the mouthpiece points , there are mult number of Rwandan pressure groups exposing the evile thing the man Andrew is paid to praise imposes to that country and finnally to the region.
You hear Kagame killing machinaries arrested in Kampala uganda or when they have killed arefugee, you hear them in Congo human rigths organisations sounding loudly of what Kagame hitmen has done,
You hear in Kenya a Rwandan deplomate being deported in conection of killing political refugees, south africa has called her deplomate because of kagame’s atempt to kill arefugee in their land, USA has depoted adeplomate in connection of attempet to muder a refugee, UK has warned strongly Rwanda of their attempt to kill refugees in their land, Sweden has depoted adeplote in connection with attempt to kill a journalist in exile! What is wrong with Kagame? When he does not kill he cant sleep? What development Rwanda will be proude of when its nationals are killed inside our land and in exile. Andrew Mwenda deserves to be prosecuted due to the pain and blood of Congolese and Rwandans he keeps to under value because of blood cheques he gets from his payee master the regional man eator president Paul Kagame of Rwanda.
Do not defend the satan of the region.He has killed 2 presidents of BURUNDI,one from Rwanda, 2 from Congo and 6 millions of people in the region. How could dare to defend suxh shit of evil? You must have your brain washed!
All of you are enermy of peace,prosperity and dignity. You are liars and evilish and all your agenda of keeping our country into hell wont prevail. Kagame has done his job and i do believe that if it wasnt for him, you would not be able to reason, remember where u have come from! You guys will never ever do harm to Rwanda soon or later you will repent of turnishing and black mailing your country. Most Rwandans are happy with the way are governed, murata inyuma ya huye kandi ntabayoboke muzabona.
6orZKS Looking forward to reading more. Great blog. Fantastic.
I appreciate you sharing this blog post.Really thank you! Will read on…
I appreciate you sharing this blog.Much thanks again. Will read on…
Thanks so much for the blog post.Much thanks again. Will read on…
Say, you got a nice blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Awesome.
Thanks-a-mundo for the blog post.Much thanks again. Keep writing.
Im thankful for the post. Really Great.
I loved your article post.Thanks Again. Great.
I really enjoy the article post. Will read on…